⇨ 671 Sandhill Rd Pequea, PA 17565

First recorded around 1765, Sickman’s Mill has taken on many roles over the years, from distillery and working mill to campground, antique mall, and wedding venue.

According to Uncharted Lancaster, the property is said to be haunted by the spirit of Frederick Pfeifer, who died on December 1, 1845 while transporting wheat to the mill and never reached his destination. During its campground days in the 1970s and 1980s, guests often reported seeing an eerie green glow in the third-floor windows, now one of the mill’s most enduring legends.

⇨ 212 East Main St. Lititz, PA 17543

The Mary Dixon Chapel, located on the campus of Linden Hall School in Lititz, was built in the 1880s as a tribute to Mary Dixon, a student who died of tuberculosis at just 19. Commissioned by her grieving father, the Gothic-style chapel stands as a lasting memorial to loss and remembrance. Today, it’s considered one of Lancaster County’s most haunted sites, with reports that Mary Dixon’s spirit still lingers within the chapel. Some students have even claimed to see a young girl wandering the chapel and nearby halls, believed to be Mary herself.

⇨ 12 N Prince St, Lancaster, PA 17603

The Fulton Theatre, established in 1852 in Lancaster, was built on the site of the city’s pre-Revolutionary jail, where the last fourteen members of the Conestoga nation were massacred in 1763. Ghostly activity is common inside the theatre, including sightings of “The Whistler,” a man in a white suit and straw boater hat who drifts through the halls and seems to follow performers, especially when a line or lyric is misspoken. Some have also reported hearing unexplained screams and eerie whispers during rehearsals and performances.

⇨ 880 Chickies Hill Rd, Columbia, PA 17512

Chickies Rock County Park is a scenic natural preserve in Lancaster County, known for its massive quartzite cliffs rising above the Susquehanna River. According to local legend, the cliffs were the site of a tragic Lover’s Leap involving a Native American couple, Wanunga and Wanhuita. After a dispute over love and betrayal, both fell to their deaths, and visitors have reported hearing Wanhuita’s screams echo across the cliffs. Others have claimed to see a colonial-dressed man on the rock or Wanunga’s spirit near a nearby tunnel on overcast days and evenings

⇨ 525 W Frederick St building 8, Lancaster, PA 17603

Built in the 1850s following the merger of Franklin and Marshall colleges, Old Main is the iconic Gothic Revival administration building at the college campus in Lancaster, PA. According to local lore, Old Main was constructed on what was once Lancaster’s “Gallows Hill”, the city’s highest point where convicted criminals were publicly executed before 1834. Today, reports of paranormal activity include the building’s bell tolling on its own in the middle of the night, even when no one is there, making Old Main one of Lancaster’s most enduring ghost stories.

⇨ 102 N Market St, Mount Joy, PA 17552

Established in 1876 by German immigrant Alois Bube, this historic brewery and hotel features preserved 19th‑century architecture and underground Catacombs. Over the years, guests and staff have reported numerous paranormal experiences, from sightings of a young woman in a long gown believed to be a member of the Bube family to shadow figures, unexplained voices, and objects moving on their own. In the catacombs, some visitors describe cold touches and eerie sensations, while others have heard phantom laughter or seen figures vanish into thin air.

⇨ 230 Locust Grove Rd, Bainbridge, PA 17502

Haldeman Mansion was originally built in the late 1700s and expanded starting in 1811 by the Haldeman family, overlooking the Susquehanna River. Numerous reported sightings of spirits at the property include a grouchy man, a young girl and boy, an English woman sometimes accompanied by the scent of rosewater, and a jovial female servant heard singing or humming. Paranormal lore attributes much of this activity to more than 90 unmarked graves uncovered on the property during plumbing and electrical work, and investigators have captured unexplained voices and anomalous sounds during exploratory visits.

⇨ 280 W Front St, Marietta, PA 17547

Built in 1823 to serve canal workers and train travelers, the Railroad House Inn has a long history as a lodging and social hub. Guests and staff over the years have reported paranormal experiences. Sightings often include the ghost of a young blonde girl in Victorian‑style clothing seen wandering the property, and many people have felt unexplained cold spots or eerie sensations in different rooms. In the kitchen, utensils and objects have been found moved or scattered with no explanation, and Room 6 in particular is known for spontaneous drops in temperature and unsettling energy. Other witnesses describe seeing shadowy figures and hearing unexplained sounds throughout the building.

⇨ 881 Rockford Rd, Lancaster, PA 17602

Built around 1794 by General Edward Hand, Rock Ford Mansion is a historic Georgian‑style home and museum that showcases early American life. The mansion carries a reputation for the eerie and unexplained. In 1807, after the tragic death of Hand’s eldest son, John, visitors and staff have reported feeling heavy, oppressive energy in certain rooms and hearing footsteps or voices when no one is present. Paranormal accounts include shadowy figures in period dress, phantom footsteps, and strange sounds echoing through the halls, particularly during candlelight tours after dark.